EST · MMXXVI
Home/Insights/Technology & DeFi/Points Programmes and Pre-Token Incentives: Legal Risk
Token Offerings & Securities

Points Programmes and Pre-Token Incentives: Legal Risk

Points Programmes and Pre-Token Incentives: Legal Risk. Independent digital-asset law for exchanges, issuers and funds. Cross-border scope, fixed-fee engagement

A DeFi protocol preparing to launch a governance token runs a six-month points programme rewarding users for deposits, referrals and test-network participation. The whitepaper describes the points as "non-transferable community engagement credits with no monetary value." Three months after launch, the project announces that points will convert to tokens at a known ratio, and secondary markets emerge where participants trade their points eligibility via wrapped derivatives. The general counsel asks: have we just created an investment contract under US law, and is the protocol now an unregistered issuer across multiple jurisdictions?

The legal question is not whether the points themselves were marketed as investments. It is whether the programme – the structure of accumulation, the expectation of token conversion and the economic reality participants understood – amounts to an offer of securities before the token exists. As MiCA takes effect across the EU, as VARA in Dubai refines its rulebooks and as the SEC intensifies enforcement against pre-launch incentive structures, the classification turns on what the participant reasonably expected to acquire and when that expectation crystallised. The programme's label does not settle the analysis; the rights, timelines and disclosures do.

This page examines how regulators across the major digital-asset hubs assess points programmes and pre-token incentive structures, where the securities-law boundary lies, what documentation reduces exposure and when a project should engage counsel. It addresses classification tests, disclosure obligations, consumer-protection overlays and the structural choices that move a programme from legal ambiguity into a defensible framework. The perspective is cross-border: a token issuer typically faces users in dozens of jurisdictions, and the analysis stacks.

What is a points programme in Web3 context?

A points programme in the digital-asset sector is a pre-launch incentive mechanism by which a protocol rewards user activity – deposits into a liquidity pool, referrals, test-network transactions, social-media engagement – with non-monetary credits denominated in "points," often with the stated or implied expectation that those points will later convert to governance or utility tokens at a disclosed or undisclosed ratio. The programme runs before the token exists or before it is publicly distributed, and its legal exposure arises not from what the points are called but from what participants understand they are acquiring.

Unlike a traditional loyalty programme tied to commercial purchases, a Web3 points structure often involves no purchase at the time points accrue. The user locks capital, refers other participants or performs tasks that increase the protocol's total-value-locked or network effect. The issuer does not immediately distribute a token because the token's legal classification, the regulatory perimeter and the tax position remain uncertain, or because the project wants traction data before committing to token economics. The points create an interim relationship, and the legal character of that relationship is the risk.

Projects describe points as "community credits," "engagement rewards" or "testnet XP," and the initial terms frequently state that points carry no monetary value, are non-transferable and do not constitute an investment. The stated intention is to avoid securities classification by eliminating the expectation of profit. But intention is not determinative. Where a participant reasonably expects that points will convert to a tradable token at a future date, and where the value of that token depends on the efforts of the issuer, the structure begins to resemble an investment contract under the tests applied by the SEC, by courts interpreting MiCA's token regimes and by regulators in Singapore and Hong Kong.

For a scoped classification assessment before you launch the programme, contact OBOLUS at info@oboluslaw.com. The process above describes the standard path. Your facts – the token economics, the jurisdictions where users sit and the ratio-disclosure timing – change the analysis.

When do points become securities under applicable tests?

Points become securities when the relationship between the participant and the issuer meets the definition of an investment contract or a transferable security under the law of the forum where the participant or the issuer sits. The question is not whether the points themselves trade on a secondary market – though that is evidence – but whether the arrangement, viewed at inception, involves an investment of value with an expectation of profit derived primarily from the efforts of others.

Under US law, the Howey test asks four questions: (1) an investment of money, (2) in a common enterprise, (3) with an expectation of profits, (4) derived from the efforts of others. The SEC's position, articulated in enforcement actions and in the Strategic Hub for Innovation and Financial Technology framework, is that a pre-token structure meets Howey when participants contribute capital or measurable effort in exchange for an interest they reasonably expect will appreciate based on the issuer's post-launch development. A participant who deposits stablecoins into a liquidity pool to earn points, where the whitepaper states that points will convert to tokens upon launch, has contributed value. If the token's utility depends on the protocol going live and attracting users – both issuer efforts – the third and fourth prongs are satisfied. The fact that the points are not yet tradable does not defeat classification.

In the European Union under MiCA, the focus is on whether the arrangement amounts to an offer of crypto-assets that qualify as transferable securities under the existing EU securities framework. A pre-token structure that gives the participant a contractual right to receive tokens at a future date may be treated as a financial instrument if that right is itself transferable or fungible. The MiCA whitepaper regime applies where the token is not a security; but if the pre-issuance relationship itself constitutes a security, the prospectus rules under the Prospectus Regulation apply instead, and national competent authorities retain jurisdiction. The issuer cannot side-step the analysis by saying "the token is not a security" if the pre-commitment structure is.

In Singapore, the Payment Services Act defines a digital payment token and excludes securities. The Monetary Authority of Singapore has indicated that a points programme may fall under securities regulation if the points represent a right to acquire tokens that themselves carry profit expectations. The question is whether the economic substance of the arrangement at the time points accrue is an investment. The label "points" is irrelevant. A participant who locks SGD-equivalent stablecoins for six months to earn points, with a published conversion ratio to a governance token that will trade post-launch, is economically in the position of a pre-sale purchaser. The regime treats it accordingly.

VARA in Dubai applies an activity-based licensing model. A token offering – whether structured as a direct sale, a pre-commitment or a points conversion – falls under VARA's Token Offerings rulebook if it involves the offer or issue of virtual assets to the public in or from Dubai. The analysis is functional. If a participant understands that accumulating points is the method to acquire tokens before public distribution, and if the issuer's marketing or documentation creates that understanding, the programme is an offering. The absence of immediate token delivery does not change the characterisation.

What factors indicate an investment intent in a points structure?

Several factors, drawn from case law, regulatory guidance and enforcement actions across the major hubs, indicate that a points programme carries investment intent sufficient to trigger securities classification. No single factor is dispositive; regulators and courts assess the totality of circumstances.

First: capital lock or measurable economic contribution. If participants must deposit assets, lock liquidity or forgo alternative uses of capital to earn points, they have made an investment. A pure engagement task – retweeting a post, joining a Discord – does not involve capital. Locking USDT in a lending pool for three months does. The SEC's position in recent cases is that even network-participation effort (validating transactions, providing computational resources) can constitute investment where the participant incurs costs or opportunity costs.

Second: stated or implied conversion ratio. If the programme documentation or the issuer's public communications reference a points-to-token ratio ("1,000 points = 1 governance token"), or if the ratio is calculable from disclosed total supply and points distribution, participants reasonably understand they are acquiring a right to future tokens. That right is an investment interest. The expectation crystallises when the ratio becomes known, and the securities exposure may date back to the programme's launch if the ratio was always intended.

Third: secondary trading or wrapped derivatives. If third-party platforms create markets for points – either by allowing account transfers or by wrapping points eligibility into tradable contracts – the economic reality is that points have become liquid investments before token launch. The issuer may not control secondary markets, but their existence is strong evidence that participants view points as profit-bearing assets. Regulators treat this as confirmation of investment character.

Fourth: issuer control over value realisation. If the ultimate value of points depends on the issuer's efforts – completing protocol development, securing exchange listings, launching features that drive token demand – then profits derive from the efforts of others, satisfying the fourth Howey prong. A programme in which points value is entirely algorithmic and user-driven (rare in practice) presents lower risk. A programme where the issuer chooses the launch date, the token supply and the go-to-market strategy presents classic investment-contract facts.

Fifth: marketing tone and target audience. Promotional materials that emphasise "early access," "allocations," "get in before the token drops" or "exclusive eligibility" signal to participants that the programme is an investment opportunity. Courts and regulators look at the language the project used to attract participants. A framing of "help us test the protocol" with incidental rewards is materially different from "accumulate points now, maximise your token allocation later." The distinction is evidentiary but significant.

What disclosures reduce classification risk and pre-empt enforcement?

No disclosure can convert an investment contract into something else if the economic substance meets the definition. But clear, accurate and prominently placed disclosures can reduce the risk that participants form reasonable expectations the issuer did not intend, can provide evidentiary support that the arrangement was not a security and, critically, can satisfy consumer-protection standards even if securities classification ultimately applies. The disclosure strategy addresses both securities exposure and the separate question of unfair or misleading conduct under consumer law.

A defensible points programme document includes the following elements. First: a clear statement of what points are not. "Points are non-transferable, have no monetary value, confer no legal or beneficial interest in the protocol or any future token, and do not constitute an investment or a security. The issuer makes no commitment to launch a token, and participants should not expect financial return." This language must appear at the top of the terms, not buried in a disclaimer section.

Second: an explicit non-commitment on token conversion. "If a token is launched, the issuer may, at its sole discretion, allocate tokens to points holders. The ratio, the timing and the eligibility criteria are not fixed and may change or may not occur." The purpose is to negate the expectation-of-profit element. In practice, issuers rarely omit all reference to future tokens – because participants would not engage without it – so the framing is critical. The disclosure says "possible," not "guaranteed."

Third: no promises on value, liquidity or exchange listing. A common enforcement trigger is language like "tokens will be listed on major exchanges" or "early participants receive exclusive allocations." These statements create profit expectations. The safer framing is: "The issuer does not control secondary markets and makes no representation that any token will trade or be listed." The risk is that participants ignore this language if the marketing contradicts it, so the programme's promotional materials must align with the written terms.

Fourth: a clear description of programme mechanics, vesting and eligibility. If the issuer reserves the right to change point-accumulation rules, to cap distributions or to exclude categories of participants (e.g., residents of restricted jurisdictions), those terms must be stated up front. Changing the rules mid-programme without disclosure increases consumer-law exposure even if securities classification is avoided. In the EU, the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive and national consumer-protection regimes apply to pre-token structures. A material omission or a misleading presentation is actionable regardless of whether the arrangement is a security.

Fifth: jurisdiction and dispute-resolution clauses that avoid multiplicity. A points programme is likely to attract participants globally. The terms should specify governing law and dispute resolution (arbitration is common) and should include a clear statement of restricted territories. "This programme is not available to residents of [list], and participation from those jurisdictions is prohibited." Enforcement risk increases where a US-person participant is involved, because the SEC asserts jurisdiction over offers made to US persons regardless of where the issuer sits.

In our cross-border practice, we have seen disclosure mitigate enforcement exposure in situations where the issuer genuinely had not committed to token issuance and where the programme mechanics supported that position. We have also seen cases where disclosure was comprehensive but the economic reality – published conversion ratios, issuer statements on social media, secondary-market pricing – created investment expectations that overrode the written terms. The documents matter, but they are not a shield if the substance contradicts them.

If a prior application stalled or an account was closed, a second read can surface the structural reason and the route back. For a scoped documentation review, write to info@oboluslaw.com.

How do the major hubs approach points programmes specifically?

Regulatory positions vary, but a pattern is emerging across the leading digital-asset jurisdictions: the programme's form does not determine its classification; the participant's reasonable understanding does. The frameworks below represent the current enforcement and guidance posture; none has issued definitive rules on points structures because the category is recent.

In the United States, the SEC has brought enforcement actions against token issuers who conducted private sales or pre-launch commitments without registration, treating those arrangements as securities offerings. The Strategic Hub guidance framework, updated periodically, signals that the agency views pre-token incentive structures with scepticism. The position is that if the participant is induced to contribute value in exchange for an interest that will appreciate based on the issuer's efforts, it is an investment contract at the time of contribution, not at token launch. Points that convert to tokens at a known ratio, where the issuer controls launch timing, meet this test. Projects targeting US participants must assume Howey applies, which typically means either a registered offering or a Regulation D private placement (with accredited-investor restrictions) or a Regulation S offshore-only structure. None of these regimes fits a decentralised points drop well, and the tension remains unresolved.

Under MiCA, which took effect for stablecoin issuers and will extend to other crypto-assets in phases, the classification question asks whether the token (or the pre-token commitment) is a transferable security within the meaning of existing EU law. If it is, the EU's Prospectus Regulation applies, and the issuer needs a prospectus approved by a national competent authority unless an exemption applies (small offers, qualified investors). If the token is not a security, the MiCA whitepaper regime applies instead. Points programmes sit awkwardly between these regimes. ESMA has indicated in guidance that any instrument giving a right to acquire crypto-assets may itself be a financial instrument if that right is transferable. The practical effect is that a points programme with a fixed conversion ratio and a transferable or fungible eligibility may be treated as a pre-sale of securities, triggering the heavier prospectus requirements. Issuers structuring under MiCA often avoid fixed ratios and avoid creating any instrument (even a smart-contract claim) that can be transferred between participants.

VARA in Dubai requires any person making a token offering in or from Dubai to be licensed and to comply with the Token Offerings rulebook. The framework is disclosure-based, not classification-based: if you are offering virtual assets to the public, you file a statement with VARA and you publish specified information. A points programme that creates a reasonable expectation of token receipt is functionally an offering. The rulebook requires disclosure of the terms, the risks and the issuer's financials. The licensing path (a VARA Virtual Asset Service Provider licence, activity: issuance) is not fast, and the regime's application to pre-token structures is still being clarified through market practice. Projects physically present in Dubai or marketing to UAE residents must engage with VARA early.

Singapore's MAS has taken a principles-based approach. The Payment Services Act excludes securities from the definition of digital payment tokens, so the threshold question is whether the token is a capital-markets product. The MAS's Digital Token Offering Guide, issued before recent enforcement tightening, indicates that a pre-sale or a commitment to deliver tokens at a future date is a securities offering if the token itself would be a security. But points that do not confer a contractual right – where the issuer retains discretion – fall into a grey area. The authority has signalled through private guidance that it will look at the economic substance and the marketing. A project that publicly states "points guarantee token allocation" is making a securities offering. A project that says "we may reward participants at our discretion" is on safer ground, provided the actual conduct matches the terms.

In Hong Kong, the Securities and Futures Commission's position is that token offerings are regulated as securities if the tokens represent equity or debt interests. The SFC has not published specific guidance on points programmes, but the principle is clear: an arrangement that gives the participant a future entitlement to a profit-bearing token is a securities arrangement. The SFC's Virtual Asset Trading Platform regime requires exchanges to list only tokens that have been assessed for securities character, and an unregistered points-to-token structure may render the resulting token unlisted. Issuers aiming for Hong Kong distribution should assume SFC licensing will be required if the token has any investment element.

What are the common structural mistakes in points programmes?

The first mistake is publishing the conversion ratio too early. When an issuer announces "10,000 points = 1 token" before the token's legal classification and distribution plan are settled, participants immediately price the points as pre-launch tokens. The issuer has created an investment interest and cannot un-create it by later disclaiming it. A safer approach is to defer ratio disclosure until the token structure is final and the offering is compliant in the target jurisdictions. The trade-off is that ambiguity reduces participant engagement, but ambiguity is less costly than an enforcement action.

The second mistake is allowing or tolerating secondary trading. Some projects actively integrate with over-the-counter desks or NFT marketplaces to "enable points trading," reasoning that decentralisation insulates the issuer. It does not. Courts and regulators treat the existence of secondary markets as evidence that the issuer intended points to be investments, and they hold issuers responsible for the ecosystem they foster. If the project's documentation prohibits transfer but the issuer does nothing when transfers occur on-chain or via account sales, the disclaimer is undermined. The enforceable position is: prohibit transfers in the smart contract, monitor for evasion and terminate accounts that violate the terms. That approach is not developer-friendly but it is legally defensible.

The third mistake is inconsistent messaging. The legal terms say "no investment, no guarantee," but the Twitter account, the Medium posts and the founder's podcast interviews say "get in early, accumulate points, secure your allocation." Regulators and courts give more weight to the marketing than to the fine print. The legal structure must align with the commercial narrative, or the commercial narrative will define the legal exposure.

The fourth mistake is failing to restrict participation by jurisdiction. A token issuer whose home regulator treats the token as a utility may still face SEC enforcement if even one US person participated in the points programme. The safe path is geo-blocking, KYC-gating or both, enforced at the smart-contract level where possible. Disclaimers in the terms that say "US persons may not participate" are not sufficient if the protocol's front end does not enforce the restriction. In practice, geo-blocking is easily circumvented (VPNs), so projects add an attestation step and treat violation as a breach, reserving the right to claw back allocations. This does not eliminate risk but it creates a paper trail that the issuer tried to comply.

The fifth mistake is launching the programme before engaging counsel. The classification analysis and the disclosure drafting should happen before the first point is issued, because the legal structure constrains the programme's design. Trying to retrofit compliance after the fact – re-drafting terms, adding disclaimers, restricting jurisdictions retrospectively – is expensive, disruptive and often ineffective. A business that discovers mid-programme that it is conducting an unregistered securities offering has limited options: shut down the programme (and face participant backlash), apply for registration (slow and uncertain), restructure the token to avoid classification (may be impossible if the economics are already set), or launch in a compliant jurisdiction only (narrowing the user base). All these outcomes are costlier than structuring the programme correctly at the outset.

What is the documentation stack for a compliant points programme?

A legally defensible points programme rests on three documents: the programme terms, the smart-contract code and, where applicable, the token whitepaper. Each document must be internally consistent and must align with the others. The stack exists to (1) define the legal relationship between the issuer and participants, (2) manage securities-classification exposure and (3) provide a record for regulators and for disputes.

The programme terms are the master document. They state what points are, how they are earned, what rights (if any) participants have, what the issuer may do unilaterally and what happens at programme termination. Key clauses: (a) a statement that points are not securities and confer no ownership interest; (b) a reservation of discretion on token issuance (no guarantee); (c) a clear description of accumulation mechanics (tasks, time periods, caps); (d) a right for the issuer to amend the programme, to cap accruals or to terminate it without liability; (e) prohibited jurisdictions and a participant attestation of compliance; (f) a disclaimer of warranties and a limitation of liability; (g) a choice of law and dispute resolution clause. The terms must be presented to every participant before they can accumulate points – a click-through acceptance on the front end, recorded on-chain or off-chain.

The smart-contract code implements the terms. It enforces non-transferability (points are credited to an address and cannot be moved), it applies any vesting schedule and it controls the conversion or termination logic. The contract should include an admin function that allows the issuer to revoke points if a participant is later found to be ineligible (e.g., a sanctioned address, a restricted-territory user who bypassed geo-blocking). The contract must not create a fungible ERC-20 or equivalent token that can be traded on DEXs; instead, it typically uses a soulbound or non-transferable-NFT model. This technical choice is load-bearing for the legal argument that participants do not hold an investment instrument.

The token whitepaper, if it exists before or during the points programme, must not contradict the programme terms. A whitepaper that describes the points programme as a "community airdrop" and then details the token's expected appreciation driven by protocol growth is creating profit expectations. The safer structure is to publish the whitepaper only after the points programme closes, or to include a statement in the whitepaper that the points programme is separate and discretionary. If the whitepaper is required under MiCA or under the issuer's home jurisdiction, it must disclose the points programme as a distribution mechanism and must state that allocations are not guaranteed.

Supporting documents include: (a) a compliance memo (internal) documenting the classification analysis and the jurisdictions targeted; (b) participant communications (announcement posts, FAQs) that use the same language as the legal terms and avoid hype; (c) a record of geo-blocking measures and restricted-territory exclusions; (d) if conversion occurs, a snapshot and allocation table showing the final points-to-token calculation, with an explanation of any adjustments. These documents form the defence if a regulator asks: how did you ensure this was not a securities offering? The answer must be evidenced, not asserted.

How does token classification interact with points-programme exposure?

The legal character of the points programme and the legal character of the token itself are separate analyses, but they interact. If the token, once issued, is a security, then the points programme that pre-sold or pre-allocated that token is presumptively a securities offering. If the token is not a security (because it is purely a utility or governance token with no profit expectation), the points programme may still be a security if the programme itself created investment expectations distinct from the token's later use. The issuer cannot assume that a "utility token" label resolves the pre-launch structure.

Under MiCA, the token regimes distinguish asset-referenced tokens, e-money tokens and "other" crypto-assets. The first two categories carry issuer-authorisation requirements and reserve-backing obligations. The third category – which includes most DeFi governance tokens and utility tokens – requires only a whitepaper unless the token qualifies as a transferable security under existing EU law. The classification question turns on whether the token confers profit rights or administrative rights. A governance token that gives holders voting power over protocol parameters, with no revenue share and no equity-like interest, is typically not a security. But if the points programme that pre-allocated that token involved participants locking capital with the expectation that the issuer's efforts would drive token value, the programme may be a securities offering even though the final token is not a security. The mismatch is legally awkward and not uncommon.

In the United States, the SEC applies the Howey test to tokens and applies the same test to the pre-token structure. A token that is a security under Howey cannot be distributed without registration or an exemption. But the SEC has also indicated that a token initially issued as a security may later be treated as non-security if it becomes sufficiently decentralised (the issuer no longer exerts control and the value no longer depends on the issuer's efforts). The timeline matters: a points programme conducted while the protocol is centralised and under the issuer's control is almost always an investment contract, even if the token, once fully decentralised, is not. This "decentralisation over time" position is not binding law and is contested, but it is the SEC's working framework.

For projects structuring under VARA, the regime's activity-based model applies to both the token and the pre-issuance structure. If you are issuing virtual assets in or from Dubai, you need a VARA licence and you file under the Token Offerings rulebook. The classification of the token – whether it is a security or not – is less significant than the fact of issuance. The disclosure obligations are the same. This simplifies the interaction: if you are doing a points programme and you are in Dubai's perimeter, you structure it as a VARA-compliant offering from the start.

Where do consumer-protection and unfair-practices rules apply?

Securities classification is not the only regulatory risk. A points programme that avoids securities law may still violate consumer-protection rules if it is misleading, if it fails to disclose material terms or if it changes the terms retroactively to participants' detriment. In the European Union, the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive prohibits misleading actions and omissions in commercial relationships with consumers. National implementations (e.g., the UK's Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations) apply to digital-asset activities. A statement that "points convert to tokens" followed by a unilateral decision not to issue tokens may be a misleading omission or a bait-and-switch.

In the United States, the Federal Trade Commission has authority over unfair or deceptive acts or practices, and state attorneys general enforce state consumer-protection statutes. A points programme marketed to US persons that fails to deliver on stated terms, or that changes vesting schedules without notice, may trigger FTC scrutiny even if the SEC does not classify it as a securities offering. The FTC's threshold is lower: did the business make a material representation that was likely to mislead a reasonable consumer? If yes, it is actionable.

Under VARA and other Gulf regimes, the concept of "fair treatment of clients" is embedded in the conduct rules. A VARA-licensed entity conducting a points programme must disclose the terms clearly, must not make false or misleading statements and must apply the terms consistently. A failure to do so is a licensing breach, separate from any securities-law issue. The regulator can suspend the licence, impose penalties or require remediation.

The practical implication is that even if a project structures the points programme to avoid securities classification, it must still treat participants fairly and honour the stated terms. The documentation must not over-promise, the mechanics must match the written description and any changes must be communicated and applied prospectively unless the terms explicitly reserved retroactive amendment (which itself may be unenforceable as an unfair term in some jurisdictions). In our practice we have seen enforcement interest from consumer-protection authorities in cases where token issuers terminated points programmes without explanation or changed conversion ratios after participants had locked capital for months. The legal theory was not securities fraud; it was unfair commercial practice.

What is the cross-border reality for a multi-jurisdiction points programme?

A points programme rarely sits in a single jurisdiction. The issuer may be incorporated in one place, the development team in another, the servers in a third and the participants distributed globally. The legal question is: which jurisdictions' laws apply, and which regulators have enforcement reach? The answer is: any jurisdiction where the programme is accessible and where participants are located may assert jurisdiction, and multiple regimes may apply concurrently.

The issuer's home jurisdiction is the first layer. If the issuer is a Dubai entity operating under a VARA licence, VARA's rules apply to the programme regardless of where participants sit. If the issuer is a BVI company with no local licence requirement, the BVI regime may not regulate the programme, but the jurisdictions where participants are located will. The second layer is the participant's location. The SEC asserts jurisdiction over offers made to US persons, even if the issuer is foreign and the offering occurs entirely online. A points programme accessible to US persons without robust geo-blocking is presumptively subject to US securities law. The third layer is the place of performance. If the smart contract is deployed on Ethereum, the legal analysis may touch on where the nodes are located, but in practice this is rarely determinative because blockchains are transnational.

The MiCA framework introduces a passporting concept for authorised issuers: a crypto-asset service provider licensed in one EU member state may offer across the EU/EEA without separate authorisation in each country. But this applies only to issuers already within the MiCA perimeter. A non-EU issuer conducting a points programme accessible to EU residents is subject to each member state's national implementation of the Prospectus Regulation and the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive. The regulatory stack is complex, and the penalties for non-compliance vary. Germany's Federal Financial Supervisory Authority (BaFin) has been active in issuing cease-and-desist orders against unlicensed token offerings. France's AMF requires pre-approval of certain token offerings. The Netherlands' AFM has penalised issuers for operating without registration. The issuer must map the target market and address each applicable regime.

In our cross-border practice, we routinely see issuers who assumed they could launch a "global" points programme and address compliance later. The result is either (a) they geo-block aggressively and lose the majority of their potential user base, or (b) they proceed without restriction and face enforcement risk in a dozen jurisdictions simultaneously. The sound path is to choose the core markets at the design stage – for example, EU under MiCA, UAE under VARA and Singapore under MAS – and to structure the programme to comply with those regimes, then to restrict access from higher-risk jurisdictions (US, China, sanctioned territories). This reduces the user base but it creates a defendable legal perimeter. A business operating a points programme that is compliant in its top three markets and explicitly geo-blocked elsewhere is in a materially better position than one that is non-compliant everywhere.

When should a project engage counsel on a points programme?

The correct time to engage counsel is before the programme is announced. The legal structure constrains the programme's design: the accumulation mechanics, the transferability rules, the jurisdiction restrictions, the disclosure language and the token-conversion mechanism all flow from the classification and compliance analysis. Trying to retrofit compliance after launch – or, worse, after participants have accumulated points under terms that turn out to be unregistered securities – is expensive and often futile.

A project should engage when it reaches the decision to launch a pre-token incentive structure. The scope at that stage is a classification memo, a documentation package and a compliance roadmap. The classification memo assesses whether the proposed structure is likely to be treated as a securities offering in the target jurisdictions, identifies the triggers (capital lock, conversion ratio, marketing tone) and proposes mitigations. The documentation package includes the programme terms, the smart-contract specifications and the template communications (announcement post, FAQs, terms-acceptance flow). The compliance roadmap maps the jurisdictions where participants are expected, identifies any licensing requirements and sets out geo-blocking and KYC measures.

The engagement is not a one-time memo. As the programme runs, facts change: the marketing evolves, secondary markets emerge, the issuer refines the token economics. Counsel should review any material change – a new promotional campaign, a partnership with an exchange, a decision to disclose the conversion ratio – before it goes live. In a recent engagement, a lending protocol added a referral incentive mid-programme that paid additional points for each new user brought in. The referral structure shifted the classification analysis because it introduced a multi-level-marketing element that some regulators treat as heightened investment-scheme exposure. We restructured the referral terms to cap payments and to require the referee to be an active participant (not a passive investor), reducing the risk. The project avoided enforcement, but the fix was possible only because counsel was engaged in real time.

The other trigger for engagement is when a regulator makes contact. If the issuer receives a request for information, a cease-and-desist letter or a Wells notice from the SEC, it is already late, but the response must be immediate and it must be legally precise. The worst outcome is a non-response or an inadequately supported response that compounds the exposure. The regulator will ask: what analysis did you do before launching the programme? What steps did you take to avoid offering securities? The answer must be documented. If it is not, the issuer is in the position of defending an unregistered offering with no compliance record. That is a hard case to win.

Is a utility label sufficient to avoid securities classification?

A common assumption is that labelling a token "utility" or describing it as a governance instrument resolves the classification question. It does not. Regulators and courts apply substance-over-form analysis: they examine what rights the token actually confers, what the participant reasonably expected when acquiring it and whether that expectation involved profit derived from the issuer's efforts. The label is evidence of intent, but it is not determinative.

A token marketed as a utility that gives holders the right to vote on protocol parameters, with no revenue share and no equity interest, is less likely to be a security than one marketed as an investment. But if the whitepaper or the promotional materials emphasise scarcity, exchange listings, price targets or "getting in early," the substance is investment, regardless of the label. The SEC's position in enforcement actions is that a token with genuine utility may still be a security at issuance if the issuer's efforts are the primary driver of value. The DAO Report (SEC, 2017) and subsequent guidance articulate this: a token may be a security when sold and a non-security later, depending on decentralisation.

Under MiCA, the framework distinguishes between crypto-assets that are transferable securities (regulated under existing EU securities law) and those that are not (regulated under MiCA's lighter whitepaper regime). The test is whether the token confers rights comparable to shares, bonds or other financial instruments. A pure governance token is less likely to be a transferable security, but if it also entitles holders to a share of protocol revenue or to appreciation linked to the issuer's commercial success, it crosses into securities territory. The label "governance token" does not change the analysis.

In practical terms, calling a token a utility and drafting the whitepaper accordingly is necessary but not sufficient. The issuer must also ensure that the marketing, the programme terms and the economic reality align with the utility framing. If they do not, the label is disregarded. A project that describes a token as utility in the legal documents but as "the next 100x" in marketing materials has created securities-law exposure that the label does not cure.

Which structure fits which project profile?

The choice of points-programme structure depends on the issuer's jurisdiction, the target participant base, the token's economics and the risk tolerance. The matrix below is indicative; every project requires a scoped analysis.

Profile A: a DeFi protocol incorporated in a non-licensing jurisdiction (e.g., BVI, Cayman), with a global user base including US persons, launching a governance token with no revenue-sharing. Risk tolerance: low. Structure: no points programme; direct airdrop to early users based on past activity, with no pre-commitment or conversion ratio. The airdrop is structured as a retrospective reward, not a prospective offer. This avoids the investment-contract analysis because there is no sale and no expectation of future profit linked to the issuer's efforts. The trade-off: lower pre-launch engagement.

Profile B: a custody platform incorporated in Dubai, licensed under VARA, launching a utility token for fee discounts and staking. Target users: UAE and GCC residents. Risk tolerance: moderate. Structure: a points programme compliant with VARA's Token Offerings rulebook, with full disclosure and no fixed conversion ratio. The programme runs for a defined period; points are capped per user; conversion is discretionary and is disclosed only at programme close. The terms state that participation is not an investment. KYC is required. This structure fits VARA's disclosure-based approach and reduces securities-classification risk by maintaining issuer discretion.

Profile C: a Layer-2 protocol incorporated in Switzerland, targeting EU users, launching a governance token under MiCA. Risk tolerance: low. Structure: no points programme; instead, a whitepaper-compliant token offering with EU passporting. If the issuer wants to reward early users, it does so via a retrospective airdrop snapshot after the token is live and compliant, not via a pre-token commitment. This avoids any pre-sale classification issue and ensures the token launch is clean under MiCA.

Profile D: a gaming metaverse incorporated in Singapore, targeting Asian markets (excluding China), launching a hybrid token with utility and governance features. Risk tolerance: moderate to high. Structure: a points programme with no capital lock (points earned purely through gameplay), no fixed conversion ratio and clear terms stating that token issuance is not guaranteed. The programme is framed as a community-building exercise. Geo-blocking applies to the US, China and restricted territories. This structure reduces securities risk because there is no investment of capital, but it carries consumer-protection risk if the issuer later decides not to issue a token. The mitigation is to under-promise in the terms and to monitor for secondary-market trading that would contradict the no-investment framing.

FAQ

Is my token a security under this regime?

It depends on whether the token, or the arrangement by which it is offered, meets the definition of a security or investment contract in the relevant jurisdiction. In the United States, the Howey test applies: an investment of value in a common enterprise with an expectation of profit from the efforts of others. Under MiCA, the question is whether the token constitutes a transferable security under existing EU law. In Singapore, VARA, Hong Kong and other major hubs, the substance of the rights conferred determines classification, not the label. A token marketed as utility but carrying profit expectations and issuer control is likely to be treated as a security. The analysis must be run before launch, and it stacks across every jurisdiction where the token is offered.

Do I need a whitepaper or prospectus?

Under MiCA, issuers of crypto-assets that are not transferable securities must publish a whitepaper and notify the relevant national competent authority. Stablecoin issuers (asset-referenced tokens and e-money tokens) need authorisation. If the token is a transferable security, the EU's Prospectus Regulation applies instead, requiring a prospectus approved by the regulator unless an exemption applies (small offers, qualified investors). In Dubai under VARA, a token offering requires a VARA licence and a Token Offerings filing. In Singapore, no whitepaper is legally mandated, but MAS expects disclosure in practice for any public token sale. In the US, there is no whitepaper requirement, but a securities offering requires either SEC registration or a private-placement exemption with disclosure to investors. The form of disclosure varies, but every regime expects transparency on the token's function, the issuer's identity, the risks and the terms of distribution.

What disclosure is required at launch?

At a minimum: the token's function (utility, governance, payment); the total supply and distribution plan; the issuer's identity and jurisdiction; the technology stack and security measures; the risks (market, regulatory, technology); any lock-ups or vesting schedules; the terms of acquisition; and a disclaimer that the token may be subject to securities regulation in certain jurisdictions. Under MiCA, the whitepaper must include financial information about the issuer if it is an authorised entity. Under VARA, the Token Offerings statement includes similar data plus the issuer's financial position. The disclosure must be accurate, not misleading and updated if material facts change. It must be accessible to prospective participants before they commit capital or effort. The principle across all regimes is that participants should understand what they are acquiring and what risks they face.

OBOLUS is an independent digital-asset law boutique acting only for businesses. We advise exchanges, custodians, token issuers and funds on licensing across more than seventy jurisdictions, on disputes and on-chain asset recovery across more than twenty-five forums, and on the tax, banking and compliance that sit around them. Digital assets are the whole of our practice. We assess classification against the substance of rights, not the marketing label, and we structure licensing, banking and tax as one mandate rather than three disconnected workstreams. To discuss your situation, contact info@oboluslaw.com.

By Roman Levitt, Technology & DeFi Counsel – Advising digital-asset businesses on smart-contract structures, token design and the regulatory perimeter of decentralised protocols.

This publication is general information about the law and does not constitute legal advice. It is not a substitute for advice tailored to your circumstances. OBOLUS accepts no liability for action taken or not taken on the basis of this material. For advice on your situation, contact info@oboluslaw.com.

Discuss your matter with OBOLUS

Tell us about the business, the jurisdictions in scope and the deadline. Every brief is confidential and we reply within two hours.

Or email info@oboluslaw.com. We treat your brief as confidential.

Tell us the task — we'll map your options in 30 minutes.

Fixed-fee packages with defined scope and SLAs. The first call is free and under NDA. Business clients only.

Map your optionsinfo@oboluslaw.com · reply < 2 hours