A token issuer preparing a public sale discovers that the same instrument can be characterized as a security under the Securities and Exchange Commission's interpretation, a commodity under the Commodity Futures Trading Commission's scope, and potentially both or neither depending on the token's stage of development and the forum in which the question is asked. The business challenge is not simply labelling the asset on a whitepaper but mapping its technical, economic and temporal profile across multiple federal regulators whose jurisdictions overlap without a legislated boundary. In US practice, the question "securities or commodity" rarely receives a binary answer; instead, the analysis identifies which regulator has the stronger claim at each stage of the token's life cycle, what registration, disclosure or exemption obligations follow, and how to document a defensible position that survives scrutiny when an enforcement action arrives.
This page unpacks the classification logic applied by the SEC, the CFTC and, at the perimeter, the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN), explains why the same token may shift categories as its ecosystem matures, sets out the practical documentation and structuring choices that reduce regulatory ambiguity, and provides two anonymized classification matters from the firm's practice. Digital-asset classification in the United States remains a matter of substance and case-by-case interpretation; there is no token registry, no safe harbour for utility claims, and no federal statute that defines the line between securities and commodities for crypto-assets. The analysis begins with the frameworks each regulator applies, moves to the common classification traps, and closes with the steps an issuer or exchange can take to map and defend the classification before launch.
The SEC framework: Howey and the investment contract
The SEC asserts jurisdiction over tokens that meet the definition of a security under Section 2(a)(1) of the Securities Act of 1933 and Section 3(a)(10) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. The definition includes "investment contract," a term the Supreme Court interpreted in SEC v W.J. Howey Co. (1946) through a four-part test: an investment of money, in a common enterprise, with an expectation of profits, derived from the efforts of others. The SEC applies Howey to tokens by asking whether buyers acquire the token with an expectation that the issuer or a promoter will build a protocol, grow a network, or execute a business plan that increases the token's value. If yes, the token is presumptively a security at issuance.
The analysis is substance-driven. A whitepaper statement that the token is "utility-only" does not override the economic reality of the rights the token confers or the manner in which it is marketed. The SEC examines the marketing materials, the project roadmap, the degree of decentralization at launch, and the role of the issuer after distribution. A token sold during a fundraising round to build a protocol that does not yet function is almost always classified as a security under Howey. The same token may move toward a non-securities characterization if the network later achieves genuine decentralization such that no single party's effort is essential to the token's utility or value – a concept the SEC staff informally discussed in the 2018 Hinman speech but never codified into a rule or safe harbour.
In our practice advising exchanges on listing decisions and issuers on pre-launch structuring, the Howey analysis turns on three checkpoints: the completeness of the protocol at the time of sale, the issuer's ongoing governance role, and the tenor of promotional statements. If buyers are told to expect the issuer to deliver future functionality that will drive adoption, Howey's fourth prong is satisfied. If the token is marketed as an investment with projected returns or liquidity events, the expectation-of-profits prong is satisfied. The effort-of-others element is the most contested: decentralized networks operated by validators or node operators reduce the issuer's control, but the SEC evaluates whether decentralization is genuine at the relevant moment or a label applied prematurely to a founder-controlled project.
For a scoped Howey analysis tailored to your project's architecture and marketing, contact OBOLUS at info@oboluslaw.com.
CFTC jurisdiction: commodities and derivatives
The Commodity Futures Trading Commission claims jurisdiction over digital assets as commodities under the Commodity Exchange Act. The CFTC's authority is clearest for Bitcoin and Ether, which multiple federal courts have recognized as commodities. The CFTC regulates the derivatives markets for these assets – futures, options, swaps – and has enforcement authority over fraud and manipulation in the spot markets, even though it does not regulate spot commodity transactions directly. The result is a layered regime: if a token is classified as a commodity, trading the token itself on a spot exchange generally falls outside CFTC registration requirements, but offering leveraged, margined or futures contracts on that token brings the platform within CFTC oversight and potentially requires registration as a derivatives clearing organization, a swap execution facility or a futures commission merchant.
The CFTC takes the position that digital assets are commodities unless they qualify as securities under the federal securities laws. This creates a default rule: if the token is not a security under Howey, it is presumptively a commodity under the CEA. The practical consequence is that a token issuer simultaneously faces the risk that the SEC classifies the token as a security at issuance while the CFTC later asserts commodity jurisdiction over secondary market activity. The overlap is not theoretical; enforcement actions have involved parallel proceedings where the SEC pursued the issuance as an unregistered securities offering and the CFTC pursued manipulation charges treating the same asset as a commodity.
The classification boundary between the two regulators is contested because Congress has not enacted a digital-asset-specific statute that allocates jurisdiction cleanly. Proposed legislation in recent sessions would have created a clearer line – designating tokens that meet certain decentralization criteria as commodities – but no bill has become law. Until statutory clarification arrives, issuers and exchanges navigate the ambiguity by analyzing both regimes in parallel and structuring the launch, the governance model and the marketing to reduce the likelihood that either regulator will view the conduct as falling within its exclusive domain.
The overlap: when both regulators assert jurisdiction
A token can satisfy elements of both definitions depending on the question being asked. At the moment of a pre-launch token sale, the SEC's focus on the investment contract formed between the issuer and the buyer often controls the classification. After the network launches, reaches operational maturity and achieves measurable decentralization, the CFTC's commodity framework may apply to secondary market trading and derivatives. The issuer does not choose one label at genesis and rely on it indefinitely; instead, classification evolves with the token's technical and governance profile.
The tension between the two agencies became public in multiple 2023 and 2024 enforcement actions where the SEC alleged that certain major tokens were securities while CFTC orders referred to overlapping tokens as commodities. Operators we advise routinely face the question: if we classify the token as a commodity and structure the offering around that assumption, will the SEC later recharacterize it as a security and pursue the initial sale as an unregistered offering? The answer turns on the substance of the arrangement at issuance. If the issuer pre-sells tokens to fund development, promises future utility that does not yet exist, and retains control over protocol upgrades, the SEC's Howey analysis will likely override a commodity label. If the protocol is functional at launch, buyers acquire the token to use it in a live system, and governance is distributed among token holders or validators, the commodity characterization gains strength.
In a recent classification matter, a decentralized exchange protocol issued governance tokens to early participants and sought to list those tokens on a U.S.-facing platform. The platform's listing committee required an analysis of whether the tokens were securities under Howey or commodities under the CEA. We structured the analysis by mapping the governance rights conferred, the protocol's operational state at token distribution, and the issuer's post-launch role. The tokens granted voting rights but no claim on revenue or profit. The protocol was fully deployed and operational; the issuer retained no unilateral upgrade authority. The marketing materials described governance participation, not investment returns. The substance supported a commodity classification for listing purposes, but the analysis explicitly noted that the SEC might view the initial distribution differently if the tokens had been sold during a capital-raise round before the protocol launched. The client proceeded with a listing limited to jurisdictions where the commodity analysis controlled and deferred U.S. retail access pending regulatory clarity.
FinCEN and money transmission: the third layer
Beyond the securities-or-commodity question, a token issuer or platform may face registration obligations under the Bank Secrecy Act if the token or the service involving the token is classified as money transmission. FinCEN, the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network within the U.S. Department of the Treasury, requires entities that accept and transmit convertible virtual currency (CVC) to register as money services businesses (MSBs) and comply with anti-money laundering (AML) program, reporting and recordkeeping rules. The definition of CVC is broad: a digital representation of value that functions as a medium of exchange, a unit of account or a store of value, and that can be exchanged for fiat or another virtual currency.
If a token meets the CVC definition and the issuer or platform acts as an intermediary in its transmission, FinCEN's MSB registration obligation applies regardless of whether the SEC classifies the token as a security or the CFTC as a commodity. The result is a three-layer analysis: Howey and the investment-contract test for securities law; the CEA commodity framework for derivatives and manipulation authority; and the BSA/MSB rules for money transmission. A single token can simultaneously trigger all three regimes, or shift among them depending on the service layer being analyzed. An issuer that pre-sells tokens to fund development may face SEC jurisdiction over the offering, CFTC jurisdiction if the token later trades on derivatives markets, and FinCEN jurisdiction if the issuer operates a platform that transmits the token between users.
Stage-driven classification: from fundraise to secondary market
The classification question often resolves into temporal stages. At the fundraising stage, when the protocol does not yet exist or is incomplete, the SEC's Howey framework is the dominant lens. Tokens sold with promises of future development are investment contracts; buyers are investing in the issuer's efforts, not acquiring a functional product. The appropriate comparator is a Simple Agreement for Future Tokens (SAFT) structure, which explicitly treats the pre-launch sale as a securities offering to accredited investors under Regulation D, with the expectation that the token will be delivered later when the network is functional and may no longer meet the Howey test.
At the launch stage, the classification depends on whether the protocol is operational and whether buyers acquire the token to use it in a functioning system or to speculate on value appreciation. A token that unlocks access to a deployed smart-contract protocol, allows holders to pay transaction fees, or grants voting rights in an active governance process is more defensibly classified as a utility or commodity. If the network is live, buyers can use the token immediately, and the issuer no longer controls the protocol's evolution, the Howey elements weaken. The shift from security to non-security is not automatic; it requires affirmative evidence of decentralization, a transition from issuer control to community or algorithmic governance, and marketing that emphasizes use rather than investment.
In the secondary-market stage, after the token has circulated, been listed on exchanges, and established a liquid market, the CFTC's commodity framework becomes more relevant, particularly if derivatives products emerge. The SEC retains enforcement authority if it determines that the initial distribution was an unregistered securities offering, but the CFTC's manipulation and fraud authority applies to trading conduct. For issuers, the implication is that classification is not a one-time determination; it must be reassessed at each stage, documented in contemporaneous legal opinions, and revisited when the protocol undergoes a governance change, a token-economics update or a new marketing campaign.
Documentation: how to build and defend a classification position
Because there is no registration mechanism for token classification in the United States and no safe-harbour rule that immunizes a good-faith classification, issuers rely on legal analysis, governance transparency and operational evidence to build a defensible position. The core document is a legal memorandum analyzing the token against Howey and the commodity definition, supported by technical documentation of the protocol's functionality, governance structure and the issuer's role at and after launch. The memorandum should address each Howey element explicitly, evaluate the degree of decentralization, and compare the token's profile to the SEC's prior enforcement positions and no-action letters.
The technical documentation must show that the protocol is operational at the time the token is distributed to the public. If the protocol is incomplete, the issuer should structure the offering as a securities transaction under Regulation D or Regulation S and deliver the token only when the network is live. Marketing materials are scrutinized: any language suggesting investment returns, liquidity events, or the issuer's future efforts to increase token value strengthens the SEC's case that the token is a security. Issuers reduce risk by framing the token as a tool for network participation, describing its utility in operational terms, and avoiding projections of value appreciation or comparisons to equity.
Governance documentation should establish that control over the protocol is distributed. If the issuer retains unilateral authority to upgrade contracts, change tokenomics or shut down the network, the "efforts of others" prong of Howey remains satisfied. Mechanisms such as on-chain voting by token holders, multi-signature wallets requiring community approval for upgrades, or time-locked governance transitions provide evidence of decentralization. The documentation package is not filed with a regulator; instead, it sits in the issuer's files and is produced if the SEC or CFTC opens an inquiry. Its purpose is to demonstrate that the classification was made in good faith, based on an analysis of the token's substance, and updated as the protocol evolved.
If a classification position later proves incorrect, the existence of a thorough legal analysis and transparent governance may mitigate penalties. The SEC has brought enforcement actions against issuers that made no classification analysis and marketed tokens as investments without considering securities law. In contrast, issuers that document the classification logic, adjust their conduct based on updated guidance, and avoid overt promotional language are less likely to face willfulness findings or elevated penalties. The analysis is not a shield against enforcement, but it is evidence that the issuer acted as a responsible operator rather than a promoter evading regulation.
The classification above describes the process we routinely apply for issuers launching in the United States or listing on U.S.-facing exchanges. Your token's architecture – the rights conferred, the protocol's deployment state, the marketing tenor – changes the outcome. To map your classification risk and document the position before launch, write to info@oboluslaw.com.
Common classification mistakes: where issuers go wrong
The first mistake is treating the utility label as dispositive. A whitepaper that calls a token a "utility token" or "access token" does not prevent the SEC from applying Howey if the economic substance of the arrangement is an investment contract. The label is marketing; the classification turns on the rights the token grants, the manner in which it is sold, and the relationship between the buyer and the issuer. A token sold to fund development, with a promise that the team will build features that drive adoption, is a security regardless of the label.
The second mistake is assuming that decentralization at some future point retroactively cleanses an initial securities offering. If the token is a security when sold, the issuer's subsequent decision to decentralize governance does not erase the obligation to register the offering or qualify for an exemption. The SEC's position is that once a securities transaction occurs, the issuer is liable for failing to register it, even if the token later becomes sufficiently decentralized that new sales would not trigger Howey. The implication is that issuers must get the classification right at issuance; they cannot sell tokens as securities without registration and later argue that decentralization moots the issue.
The third mistake is ignoring the CFTC after concluding that a token is not a security. If the token is not a security under Howey, it is presumptively a commodity, and offering leveraged trading, futures or other derivatives on that token brings the platform within CFTC jurisdiction. Exchanges that list tokens they classify as non-securities sometimes fail to assess whether their margin or perpetual-swap products require CFTC registration. The result is an enforcement action for operating an unregistered derivatives exchange, even though the underlying token was correctly classified as a commodity.
The fourth mistake is marketing the token with investment-return language while asserting a utility classification. Statements such as "early buyers will benefit as the network grows," "limited supply ensures value appreciation," or "the token will be listed on major exchanges" all suggest that buyers are acquiring the token for speculative gain rather than immediate use. The SEC reads marketing materials closely; any language that frames the token as an investment undermines a utility or commodity defense. Issuers should draft promotional materials with the assumption that the SEC will review them and apply Howey to every forward-looking statement.
Cross-border considerations: when U.S. classification matters abroad
A token issuer domiciled outside the United States may still face SEC or CFTC jurisdiction if the token is sold to U.S. persons, marketed in the United States, or listed on a U.S.-based exchange. The securities laws apply extraterritorially when the conduct or the effects test is met: conduct in the United States in furtherance of the transaction, or a substantial effect in the United States from offshore conduct. The CFTC similarly asserts authority over offshore platforms that accept U.S. customers for derivatives trading. For non-U.S. issuers, the classification question often arises when a U.S. exchange considers listing the token or when U.S. investors participate in a token sale.
The practical consequence is that a token structured to comply with MiCA in the European Union, or licensed as a recognized virtual asset in the ADGM, must still be analyzed against U.S. law if there is any U.S. nexus. The classifications do not align: a token that qualifies as an "other crypto-asset" under MiCA may still be a security under Howey if sold during a pre-launch fundraise. Issuers launching globally routinely conduct parallel classification analyses for each major jurisdiction, segment their marketing geographically, and use geofencing or investor-accreditation checks to exclude U.S. retail buyers if the U.S. classification is uncertain. For businesses sitting between the United States and another hub, the question turns on which legal stack creates the greater business opportunity and the least regulatory friction.
In a cross-border classification matter, a Swiss foundation issued governance tokens for a DeFi protocol and planned to list them on exchanges in Europe and Asia. The protocol was operational at token distribution, and Swiss counsel classified the tokens as payment tokens under FINMA guidance. The client approached OBOLUS when a U.S. exchange expressed interest in listing the token but required a Howey analysis. We evaluated the initial distribution: the tokens had been allocated to contributors and liquidity providers rather than sold in a fundraising round, the protocol was live at distribution, and the foundation retained no unilateral upgrade authority. The substance supported a non-security classification for secondary trading. We advised that the initial distribution likely avoided Howey but that any future token sale marketed to U.S. investors would require a fresh analysis. The client proceeded with the U.S. listing and implemented a compliance overlay to restrict participation in future token sales by U.S. persons unless the sale was structured under Regulation D.
Regulatory proposals: the path toward statutory clarity
Multiple bills introduced in the U.S. Congress in recent sessions have proposed a framework to allocate jurisdiction between the SEC and the CFTC. The proposals generally seek to define "digital commodity" as a digital asset on a functional blockchain that is decentralized, to assign the CFTC primary regulatory authority over digital commodities, and to preserve the SEC's authority over tokens that are securities under Howey. Proposed thresholds for decentralization have included metrics such as the absence of an issuer with unilateral control, the distribution of validation or governance authority among participants, and the operational maturity of the protocol.
No such bill has been enacted into law. The result is that the classification regime remains a judicial construct built on Howey and a patchwork of enforcement actions. The SEC and the CFTC issue guidance, speeches and enforcement settlements, but there is no codified safe harbour for tokens that meet specified decentralization criteria, no registration pathway for tokens that transition from securities to commodities, and no binding standard for when a token has achieved sufficient decentralization to exit the securities regime. Issuers operate in a state of informed uncertainty: the analysis can be structured and documented, but the outcome is not guaranteed until a court or the regulator reviews the matter.
The implication for issuers is that regulatory strategy must be built on flexibility. Classification positions should be documented but revisited when proposed legislation advances, when the SEC or CFTC issues new guidance, or when enforcement actions create new precedent. Issuers that assume a static classification and proceed without monitoring regulatory developments risk being caught by a change in the agencies' interpretation. The disciplined approach is to treat classification as a living question, update the legal analysis quarterly or when the protocol undergoes a significant change, and build governance structures that can adapt to evolving regulatory expectations.
Self-assessment checklist: evaluating your token's classification risk
An issuer or exchange can reduce classification uncertainty by working through the following checkpoints. Each question addresses a factor that the SEC or CFTC weighs in applying Howey or the commodity framework. The checklist is not a substitute for a legal opinion, but it surfaces the issues that will control the analysis.
- Is the token being sold before the protocol is fully operational? If yes, the token is presumptively a security at the point of sale.
- Are buyers told to expect future development, feature releases or network growth that will increase the token's value? If yes, the "expectation of profits" and "efforts of others" prongs of Howey are likely satisfied.
- Does the issuer retain unilateral control over protocol upgrades, tokenomics changes or governance decisions? If yes, decentralization is insufficient to defeat the "efforts of others" element.
- Is the token marketed with investment-return language, liquidity projections or comparisons to equity or revenue-sharing arrangements? If yes, the SEC will treat the marketing as evidence of a security.
- If the token grants governance rights, are those rights exercisable in a live, operational protocol, or are they contingent on future development? Rights in a live system support a utility or commodity classification; rights contingent on the issuer's future work support a security classification.
- Is the protocol deployed on-chain, with smart contracts that execute autonomously, or does functionality depend on the issuer's ongoing operational involvement? Autonomous execution supports a commodity classification; issuer-dependent operation supports a security classification.
- If the token is classified as a commodity, will the platform offer leveraged trading, perpetual swaps, futures or other derivatives on the token? If yes, CFTC registration obligations may apply to the platform.
- Is the token being distributed to U.S. persons, marketed in the United States, or planned for listing on a U.S. exchange? If yes, U.S. classification analysis is mandatory even if the issuer is domiciled offshore.
If more than two of the above factors indicate securities treatment, the issuer should structure the token launch under a securities framework (Regulation D or Regulation S) or delay the public sale until the protocol is operational and the issuer's role is reduced. If the factors point toward a commodity classification, the analysis should be documented in a legal memorandum, the marketing should be reviewed to remove investment-return language, and the governance structure should be audited for residual issuer control.
When to engage classification counsel: timing and scope
Classification analysis is most valuable before the token sale is announced. An issuer that waits until after a public token offering to assess whether the token is a security has already incurred the risk of an unregistered offering. The disciplined approach is to engage counsel during the whitepaper drafting stage, when the protocol architecture is being finalized and before marketing materials are published. The analysis informs the launch structure: if the token is likely a security at issuance, the issuer can pivot to a Regulation D private placement, deliver tokens only after the protocol is operational, or limit the offering to non-U.S. persons under Regulation S.
The scope of a classification engagement includes a review of the whitepaper, the protocol's technical documentation, the governance model, the token distribution plan, and all marketing materials. Counsel applies Howey to the token's substance, evaluates the degree of decentralization at launch, compares the profile to prior SEC enforcement actions, and identifies the classification risks. The deliverable is a memorandum that sets out the analysis, concludes whether the token is more defensibly classified as a security or a commodity, and recommends structural or marketing changes to reduce ambiguity. The memorandum is not filed with a regulator; it sits in the issuer's records and is updated when the protocol changes or new guidance is issued.
For token projects launching in the United States or targeting U.S. investors, the classification question is binary in consequence but nuanced in analysis. A mis-classification can convert a product launch into an enforcement target. If you are structuring a token sale, preparing to list on a U.S. platform, or responding to an SEC inquiry, contact OBOLUS at info@oboluslaw.com for a scoped classification opinion tied to your protocol's architecture and launch timeline.
FAQ
Is my token a security under this regime?
Your token is a security under U.S. law if it meets the Howey test: an investment of money in a common enterprise with an expectation of profits derived from the efforts of others. The analysis turns on the substance of the rights the token confers, the protocol's operational state at distribution, the issuer's ongoing role, and the marketing language. If the token is sold to fund development and buyers are told to expect value appreciation from the issuer's efforts, it is presumptively a security. If the protocol is operational at distribution, buyers use the token in a live system, and governance is decentralized, the token may be classified as a commodity. Classification is substance-driven; a utility label on the whitepaper does not control the outcome.
Do I need a whitepaper or prospectus?
If the token is a security, you are required to register the offering with the SEC or qualify for an exemption such as Regulation D or Regulation S. Registration involves filing a prospectus that discloses the risks, the use of proceeds, the management team, and the protocol's status. Most token issuers avoid full registration by limiting the offering to accredited investors under Regulation D. If the token is classified as a commodity and not a security, there is no SEC registration requirement, but best practice is to publish a whitepaper that describes the protocol's functionality, the token's technical profile, the governance model, and the team. The whitepaper is not filed with a regulator; it serves as disclosure to buyers and evidence of the issuer's good faith in the event of an inquiry.
What disclosure is required at launch?
If the token is a security, disclosure is governed by the Securities Act: you must either register the offering and file a prospectus, or qualify for an exemption and provide the disclosures required by that exemption (such as Form D under Regulation D). If the token is not a security, there is no federal disclosure mandate, but failing to disclose material risks or protocol limitations can expose the issuer to fraud claims under the CFTC's anti-manipulation authority or state-law consumer protection statutes. The prudent approach is to publish a detailed whitepaper regardless of classification, describe the protocol's operational state honestly, identify risks including regulatory uncertainty, and avoid projections of investment returns. Transparent disclosure reduces the risk that a regulator characterizes the launch as deceptive, even if the classification itself is later disputed.
Related at OBOLUS
- Token Offerings & Securities – structuring compliant token sales, whitepaper review, and classification opinions across multiple jurisdictions
- EU Transfer of Funds Regulation: Zero-Threshold Travel Rule Compliance – how the Travel Rule applies to token transfers and what compliance systems issuers and exchanges must build
- Legal Counsel for Web3 Startups – fixed-scope packages for token launches, licensing roadmaps, and compliance design from protocol concept to public sale
About OBOLUS
OBOLUS is an independent digital-asset law boutique acting only for businesses. We advise exchanges, custodians, token issuers and funds on licensing across more than seventy jurisdictions, on disputes and on-chain asset recovery across twenty-five forums, and on the tax, banking and compliance structures that sit around them. Digital assets are the whole of our practice. We assess classification against the substance of rights conferred, not the marketing label, and we document defensible positions before launch so that when regulatory scrutiny arrives, the issuer can demonstrate informed decision-making rather than willful evasion. To discuss your token's classification risk and map the disclosure, exemption or registration path for your launch, contact info@oboluslaw.com.
By Roman Levitt, Technology & DeFi Counsel – specialist in token classification, smart-contract legal architecture, and the intersection of securities law and decentralized protocols.
This publication is general information about the law and does not constitute legal advice. It is not a substitute for advice tailored to your circumstances. OBOLUS accepts no liability for action taken or not taken on the basis of this material. For advice on your situation, contact info@oboluslaw.com.